Class information for:
Level 1: MORAL RESPONSIBILITY//INCOMPATIBILISM//COMPATIBILISM

Basic class information
Class id #P Avg. number of
references		 Database coverage
of references
9769 1122 23.2 22%


Bar chart of Publication_year

Last years might be incomplete

Hierarchy of classes
The table includes all classes above and classes immediately below the current class.


Cluster id Level Cluster label #P
1 4 ECONOMICS//EDUCATION & EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH//PSYCHOL 3876184
175 3       PHILOSOPHY//PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES//SYNTHESE 58071
1306 2             PHILOSOPHY//PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES//PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH 8547
9769 1                   MORAL RESPONSIBILITY//INCOMPATIBILISM//COMPATIBILISM 1122

Terms with highest relevance score


rank Term termType Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with term
in class
1 MORAL RESPONSIBILITY authKW 928765 9% 36% 96
2 INCOMPATIBILISM authKW 862314 3% 81% 39
3 COMPATIBILISM authKW 752958 5% 54% 51
4 FREE WILL authKW 602057 9% 23% 98
5 ALTERNATIVE POSSIBILITIES authKW 559814 2% 86% 24
6 PHILOSOPHY WoSSC 368074 90% 1% 1006
7 FRANKFURT CASES authKW 353776 1% 100% 13
8 PEREBOOM authKW 274401 1% 92% 11
9 PRINCIPLE OF ALTERNATIVE POSSIBILITIES authKW 247394 1% 91% 10
10 DIRECT ARGUMENT authKW 244922 1% 100% 9

Web of Science journal categories


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with term
in class
1 Philosophy 368074 90% 1% 1006
2 Ethics 6082 8% 0% 88
3 Religion 5687 9% 0% 99
4 History & Philosophy of Science 56 1% 0% 10
5 Medical Ethics 50 0% 0% 5
6 Law 32 1% 0% 15
7 Asian Studies 22 0% 0% 4
8 Social Sciences, Interdisciplinary 16 1% 0% 10
9 Social Sciences, Biomedical 13 1% 0% 7
10 Social Issues 13 0% 0% 5

Address terms


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 PHILOSOPHY 64045 21% 1% 235
2 ABT PHILOS 27214 0% 100% 1
3 CHRISTLICHE PHILOSOPHIE 27214 0% 100% 1
4 ESSEX AUTON PROJECT 27214 0% 100% 1
5 GERIATRIC MED 27214 0% 100% 1
6 HBEREICH GEISTESWISSEN 27214 0% 100% 1
7 HUTE 27214 0% 100% 1
8 HUTE CAC 300 27214 0% 100% 1
9 IMGWF 27214 0% 100% 1
10 METAFIS 27214 0% 100% 1

Journals


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES 187269 13% 5% 146
2 PHILOSOPHICAL EXPLORATIONS 97808 2% 14% 26
3 RELIGIOUS STUDIES 69088 4% 5% 47
4 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION 63943 3% 6% 37
5 PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH 61235 6% 4% 62
6 AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY 60206 4% 5% 47
7 PHILOSOPHIA 52672 4% 5% 42
8 MIDWEST STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY 49502 2% 10% 18
9 NOUS 46643 4% 4% 49
10 PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW 29762 2% 5% 23

Author Key Words


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class		 LCSH search Wikipedia search
1 MORAL RESPONSIBILITY 928765 9% 36% 96 Search MORAL+RESPONSIBILITY Search MORAL+RESPONSIBILITY
2 INCOMPATIBILISM 862314 3% 81% 39 Search INCOMPATIBILISM Search INCOMPATIBILISM
3 COMPATIBILISM 752958 5% 54% 51 Search COMPATIBILISM Search COMPATIBILISM
4 FREE WILL 602057 9% 23% 98 Search FREE+WILL Search FREE+WILL
5 ALTERNATIVE POSSIBILITIES 559814 2% 86% 24 Search ALTERNATIVE+POSSIBILITIES Search ALTERNATIVE+POSSIBILITIES
6 FRANKFURT CASES 353776 1% 100% 13 Search FRANKFURT+CASES Search FRANKFURT+CASES
7 PEREBOOM 274401 1% 92% 11 Search PEREBOOM Search PEREBOOM
8 PRINCIPLE OF ALTERNATIVE POSSIBILITIES 247394 1% 91% 10 Search PRINCIPLE+OF+ALTERNATIVE+POSSIBILITIES Search PRINCIPLE+OF+ALTERNATIVE+POSSIBILITIES
9 DIRECT ARGUMENT 244922 1% 100% 9 Search DIRECT+ARGUMENT Search DIRECT+ARGUMENT
10 BLAMEWORTHINESS 164239 1% 46% 13 Search BLAMEWORTHINESS Search BLAMEWORTHINESS

Core articles
The table includes core articles in the class. The following variables is taken into account for the relevance score of an article in a cluster c:
(1) Number of references referring to publications in the class.
(2) Share of total number of active references referring to publications in the class.
(3) Age of the article. New articles get higher score than old articles.
(4) Citation rate, normalized to year.


Rank Reference # ref.
in cl.		 Shr. of ref. in
cl.		 Citations
1 LEVY, K , (2016) BLOCKING BLOCKAGE.PHILOSOPHIA. VOL. 44. ISSUE 2. P. 565 -582 44 88% 0
2 FISCHER, JM , (1999) RECENT WORK ON MORAL RESPONSIBILITY.ETHICS. VOL. 110. ISSUE 1. P. 93 -139 46 92% 86
3 SHABO, S , (2014) IT WASN'T UP TO JONES: UNAVOIDABLE ACTIONS AND INTENSIONAL CONTEXTS IN FRANKFURT EXAMPLES.PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES. VOL. 169. ISSUE 3. P. 379 -399 22 100% 1
4 COHEN, Y , (2017) FISCHER'S DETERMINISTIC FRANKFURT-STYLE ARGUMENT.ERKENNTNIS. VOL. 82. ISSUE 1. P. 121 -140 21 88% 0
5 LEVY, K , (2005) WHY IT IS SOMETIMES FAIR TO BLAME AGENTS FOR UNAVOIDABLE ACTIONS AND OMISSIONS.AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY. VOL. 42. ISSUE 2. P. 93-104 22 96% 1
6 ELZEIN, N , (2013) PEREBOOM'S FRANKFURT CASE AND DERIVATIVE CULPABILITY.PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES. VOL. 166. ISSUE 3. P. 553-573 16 100% 1
7 JANZEN, G , (2013) FRANKFURT CASES, ALTERNATE POSSIBILITIES, AND PRIOR SIGNS.ERKENNTNIS. VOL. 78. ISSUE 5. P. 1037-1049 16 94% 2
8 SHABO, S , (2016) ROBUSTNESS REVISED: FRANKFURT CASES AND THE RIGHT KIND OF POWER TO DO OTHERWISE.ACTA ANALYTICA-INTERNATIONAL PERIODICAL FOR PHILOSOPHY IN THE ANALYTICAL TRADITION. VOL. 31. ISSUE 1. P. 89 -106 14 100% 0
9 FISCHER, JM , (1992) RECENT WORK ON GOD AND FREEDOM.AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY. VOL. 29. ISSUE 2. P. 91-109 38 76% 5
10 COHEN, Y , (2016) COUNTERFACTUALS OF DIVINE FREEDOM.INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION. VOL. 79. ISSUE 3. P. 185 -205 17 77% 0

Classes with closest relation at Level 1


Rank Class id link
1 14306 EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHY//KNOBE EFFECT//PHILOSOPHICAL METHODOLOGY
2 23932 AKRASIA//WEAKNESS OF WILL//A PRIORI FALSITY
3 13489 BROOME//DOXASTIC VOLUNTARISM//RATIONAL REQUIREMENTS
4 22745 RELIGIOUS STUDIES//INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION//EXISTENTIAL FAITH
5 21574 DISPOSITIONS//FINKS//DISPOSITIONAL ESSENTIALISM
6 18726 LAW AND PHILOSOPHY//RETRIBUTIVISM//GRISWOLD
7 30922 CHANGE OF MIND//CRIMINAL PSYCHIAT//DAN TURNER
8 33652 EXTRAORDINARY MEANS//ALBERT GNAEGI HLTH CARE ETH SALUS//AMBROSE OF MILAN
9 12355 PHILOSOPHY//SUPEREROGATION//CONSEQUENTIALISM
10 17966 AFFECTIVE INTENTIONALITY//PHILOSOPHY//ARATIONAL ACTIONS

Go to start page