Class information for:
Level 1: PEER REVIEW//EVALUAT OFF//PEER REVIEW PROCESS

Basic class information
Class id #P Avg. number of
references		 Database coverage
of references
7260 1389 24.6 50%


Bar chart of Publication_year

Last years might be incomplete

Hierarchy of classes
The table includes all classes above and classes immediately below the current class.


Cluster id Level Cluster label #P
1 4 ECONOMICS//EDUCATION & EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH//PSYCHOL 3876184
504 3       SCIENTOMETRICS//INFORMATION SCIENCE & LIBRARY SCIENCE//BIBLIOMETRICS 21997
492 2             SCIENTOMETRICS//INFORMATION SCIENCE & LIBRARY SCIENCE//BIBLIOMETRICS 15444
7260 1                   PEER REVIEW//EVALUAT OFF//PEER REVIEW PROCESS 1389

Terms with highest relevance score


rank Term termType Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 PEER REVIEW authKW 1128604 16% 23% 221
2 EVALUAT OFF address 240053 2% 38% 29
3 PEER REVIEW PROCESS authKW 176893 1% 62% 13
4 OPEN PEER REVIEW authKW 119677 1% 78% 7
5 MANUSCRIPT REJECTION authKW 109910 0% 100% 5
6 REVIEWERS authKW 106125 1% 37% 13
7 GRANT PEER REVIEW authKW 87928 0% 100% 4
8 SCI PEER ADVISORY REVIEW SERV address 87928 0% 100% 4
9 SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING journal 87367 2% 15% 26
10 JOURNAL PEER REVIEW authKW 78504 0% 71% 5

Web of Science journal categories


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 Information Science & Library Science 22568 20% 0% 281
2 Psychology, Biological 3423 6% 0% 80
3 Humanities, Multidisciplinary 1586 4% 0% 56
4 Medicine, General & Internal 1195 15% 0% 206
5 Behavioral Sciences 802 6% 0% 81
6 Medical Ethics 587 1% 0% 18
7 History & Philosophy of Science 390 2% 0% 27
8 Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications 350 5% 0% 68
9 Social Issues 328 2% 0% 23
10 Education & Educational Research 322 4% 0% 56

Address terms


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 EVALUAT OFF 240053 2% 38% 29
2 SCI PEER ADVISORY REVIEW SERV 87928 0% 100% 4
3 STROKE EDITORIAL OFF 43964 0% 100% 2
4 ST MICHAELS HOSP NEUROL 29308 0% 67% 2
5 UNITE RECH CLIN ECON SANTE 29308 0% 67% 2
6 ADV TECHNOL SURG BRANCH 25117 0% 29% 4
7 ABT BIOGEOWISSEN 21982 0% 100% 1
8 ABT THEORET SOZIOL SOZIALANALYSEN 21982 0% 100% 1
9 ALPHA ALPHA 21982 0% 100% 1
10 AMER ASSOC ADV 21982 0% 100% 1

Journals


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class
1 SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING 87367 2% 15% 26
2 LEARNED PUBLISHING 77392 3% 9% 41
3 JOURNAL OF SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING 54643 2% 9% 27
4 RESEARCH EVALUATION 34486 2% 6% 27
5 BEHAVIORAL AND BRAIN SCIENCES 29418 6% 2% 79
6 JOURNAL OF INFORMATION ETHICS 22241 1% 11% 9
7 ACCOUNTABILITY IN RESEARCH-POLICIES AND QUALITY ASSURANCE 17275 1% 7% 12
8 SCIENTOMETRICS 11684 3% 1% 48
9 SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 5974 1% 2% 16
10 JOURNAL OF INFORMETRICS 4985 1% 2% 12

Author Key Words


Rank Term Chi square Shr. of publ. in
class containing
term		 Class's shr. of
term's tot. occurrences		 #P with
term in
class		 LCSH search Wikipedia search
1 PEER REVIEW 1128604 16% 23% 221 Search PEER+REVIEW Search PEER+REVIEW
2 PEER REVIEW PROCESS 176893 1% 62% 13 Search PEER+REVIEW+PROCESS Search PEER+REVIEW+PROCESS
3 OPEN PEER REVIEW 119677 1% 78% 7 Search OPEN+PEER+REVIEW Search OPEN+PEER+REVIEW
4 MANUSCRIPT REJECTION 109910 0% 100% 5 Search MANUSCRIPT+REJECTION Search MANUSCRIPT+REJECTION
5 REVIEWERS 106125 1% 37% 13 Search REVIEWERS Search REVIEWERS
6 GRANT PEER REVIEW 87928 0% 100% 4 Search GRANT+PEER+REVIEW Search GRANT+PEER+REVIEW
7 JOURNAL PEER REVIEW 78504 0% 71% 5 Search JOURNAL+PEER+REVIEW Search JOURNAL+PEER+REVIEW
8 PEER REVIEWERS 68690 0% 63% 5 Search PEER+REVIEWERS Search PEER+REVIEWERS
9 EDITORS 65311 1% 17% 18 Search EDITORS Search EDITORS
10 EDITORIAL PROCESS 61057 0% 56% 5 Search EDITORIAL+PROCESS Search EDITORIAL+PROCESS

Core articles
The table includes core articles in the class. The following variables is taken into account for the relevance score of an article in a cluster c:
(1) Number of references referring to publications in the class.
(2) Share of total number of active references referring to publications in the class.
(3) Age of the article. New articles get higher score than old articles.
(4) Citation rate, normalized to year.


Rank Reference # ref.
in cl.		 Shr. of ref. in
cl.		 Citations
1 LEE, CJ , SUGIMOTO, CR , ZHANG, G , CRONIN, B , (2013) BIAS IN PEER REVIEW.JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR INFORMATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY. VOL. 64. ISSUE 1. P. 2-17 71 70% 77
2 BORNMANN, L , (2011) SCIENTIFIC PEER REVIEW.ANNUAL REVIEW OF INFORMATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY. VOL. 45. ISSUE . P. 199 -245 82 66% 75
3 DEVRIES, DR , MARSCHALL, EA , STEIN, RA , (2009) EXPLORING THE PEER REVIEW PROCESS: WHAT IS IT, DOES IT WORK, AND CAN IT BE IMPROVED?.FISHERIES. VOL. 34. ISSUE 6. P. 270-279 62 95% 11
4 RESNIK, DB , ELMORE, SA , (2016) ENSURING THE QUALITY, FAIRNESS, AND INTEGRITY OF JOURNAL PEER REVIEW: A POSSIBLE ROLE OF EDITORS.SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS. VOL. 22. ISSUE 1. P. 169 -188 44 76% 4
5 MERUANE, OS , VERGARA, CG , PINA-STRANGER, A , (2016) WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW ABOUT PEER REVIEW.JOURNAL OF SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING. VOL. 47. ISSUE 2. P. 180 -212 58 68% 0
6 JEFFERSON, T , RUDIN, M , BRODNEY, FS , DAVIDOFF, F , (2007) EDITORIAL PEER REVIEW FOR IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF REPORTS OF BIOMEDICAL STUDIES.COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS. VOL. . ISSUE 2. P. - 48 81% 39
7 SOUDER, L , (2011) THE ETHICS OF SCHOLARLY PEER REVIEW: A REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE.LEARNED PUBLISHING. VOL. 24. ISSUE 1. P. 55 -72 50 62% 22
8 DALTON, MS , (1995) REFEREEING OF SCHOLARLY WORKS FOR PRIMARY PUBLISHING.ANNUAL REVIEW OF INFORMATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY. VOL. 30. ISSUE . P. 213 -250 65 75% 11
9 BRUCE, R , CHAUVIN, A , TRINQUART, L , RAVAUD, P , BOUTRON, I , (2016) IMPACT OF INTERVENTIONS TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF PEER REVIEW OF BIOMEDICAL JOURNALS: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS.BMC MEDICINE. VOL. 14. ISSUE . P. - 34 79% 0
10 BORNMANN, L , MUTZ, R , DANIEL, HD , (2010) A RELIABILITY-GENERALIZATION STUDY OF JOURNAL PEER REVIEWS: A MULTILEVEL META-ANALYSIS OF INTER-RATER RELIABILITY AND ITS DETERMINANTS.PLOS ONE. VOL. 5. ISSUE 12. P. - 42 65% 30

Classes with closest relation at Level 1


Rank Class id link
1 31118 SCIENTIFIC PAPER//MEDICAL WRITING//BIOMED IMAGING INTERVENT JOURNAL
2 29987 DOCTOR OF NURSING PRACTICE DNP PROGRAM//WRITING SUPPORT GROUP//WRITING FOR PUBLICATION
3 28191 CITATION ERRORS//QUOTATION ERRORS//ENDNOTE
4 8363 SCIENTIFIC MISCONDUCT//RESEARCH MISCONDUCT//RESEARCH INTEGRITY
5 35658 RESEARCH WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT//ASSET COMMERCIALIZATION//BIOMEDICAL WORKFORCE
6 10242 OPEN ACCESS//LEARNED PUBLISHING//INSTITUTIONAL REPOSITORIES
7 11204 PUBLICATION RATE//PUBLICATION BIAS//MEETING ABSTRACTS
8 1274 H INDEX//JOURNAL OF INFORMETRICS//SCIENTOMETRICS
9 6216 JOURNAL RANKING//JOURNAL QUALITY//JOURNAL LISTS
10 34915 CLIN B 211//COMMUNITY ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ASSESSMENT//COMMUNITY LINKED RESEARCH

Go to start page