Class information for:
Level 1: PEER REVIEW//EVALUAT OFF//MANUSCRIPT REJECTION

Basic class information
ID Publications Average number
of references		 Avg. shr. active
ref. in WoS
7399 1292 23.7 49%


Bar chart of Publication_year

Last years might be incomplete

Classes in level above (level 2)


ID, lev.
above		 Publications Label for level above
2668 2918 RESEARCH MISCONDUCT//PEER REVIEW//RESPONSIBLE CONDUCT OF RESEARCH

Terms with highest relevance score


Rank Term Type of term Relevance score
(tfidf)		 Class's shr.
of term's tot.
occurrences		 Shr. of publ.
in class containing
term		 Num. of
publ. in
class
1 PEER REVIEW Author keyword 33 17% 14% 181
2 EVALUAT OFF Address 10 34% 2% 25
3 MANUSCRIPT REJECTION Author keyword 6 80% 0% 4
4 PEER REVIEWERS Author keyword 6 80% 0% 4
5 JOURNAL PEER REVIEW Author keyword 5 63% 0% 5
6 PEER REVIEW PROCESS Author keyword 4 39% 1% 9
7 EDITORIAL PEER REVIEW Author keyword 4 75% 0% 3
8 UNIVERSAL IR SURFACE Author keyword 4 75% 0% 3
9 SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING Journal 4 14% 2% 26
10 MANUSCRIPT REVIEW Author keyword 3 50% 0% 5

Web of Science journal categories

Author Key Words


Rank Web of Science journal category Relevance score
(tfidf)		 Class's shr.
of term's tot.
occurrences		 Shr. of publ.
in class containing
term		 Num. of
publ. in
class		 LCSH search Wikipedia search
1 PEER REVIEW 33 17% 14% 181 Search PEER+REVIEW Search PEER+REVIEW
2 MANUSCRIPT REJECTION 6 80% 0% 4 Search MANUSCRIPT+REJECTION Search MANUSCRIPT+REJECTION
3 PEER REVIEWERS 6 80% 0% 4 Search PEER+REVIEWERS Search PEER+REVIEWERS
4 JOURNAL PEER REVIEW 5 63% 0% 5 Search JOURNAL+PEER+REVIEW Search JOURNAL+PEER+REVIEW
5 PEER REVIEW PROCESS 4 39% 1% 9 Search PEER+REVIEW+PROCESS Search PEER+REVIEW+PROCESS
6 EDITORIAL PEER REVIEW 4 75% 0% 3 Search EDITORIAL+PEER+REVIEW Search EDITORIAL+PEER+REVIEW
7 UNIVERSAL IR SURFACE 4 75% 0% 3 Search UNIVERSAL+IR+SURFACE Search UNIVERSAL+IR+SURFACE
8 MANUSCRIPT REVIEW 3 50% 0% 5 Search MANUSCRIPT+REVIEW Search MANUSCRIPT+REVIEW
9 GRANT PEER REVIEW 3 100% 0% 3 Search GRANT+PEER+REVIEW Search GRANT+PEER+REVIEW
10 REVIEWING PROCESS 3 60% 0% 3 Search REVIEWING+PROCESS Search REVIEWING+PROCESS

Key Words Plus


Rank Web of Science journal category Relevance score
(tfidf)		 Class's shr.
of term's tot.
occurrences		 Shr. of publ.
in class containing
term		 Num. of
publ. in
class
1 STANDS TODAY 21 57% 2% 25
2 INTERJUDGMENTAL RELIABILITY 21 85% 1% 11
3 MANUSCRIPTS 16 22% 5% 65
4 PEER REVIEWERS 14 44% 2% 25
5 MASKING AUTHOR IDENTITY 13 55% 1% 16
6 MANUSCRIPT 12 28% 3% 37
7 AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST 11 69% 1% 9
8 EDITORS 10 17% 4% 54
9 REVIEWERS 8 32% 2% 22
10 MANUSCRIPT QUALITY 7 64% 1% 7

Journals


Rank Web of Science journal category Relevance score
(tfidf)		 Class's shr.
of term's tot.
occurrences		 Shr. of publ.
in class containing
term		 Num. of
publ. in
class
1 SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING 4 14% 2% 26
2 JOURNAL OF INFORMATION ETHICS 1 11% 1% 9

Reviews


Title Publ. year Cit. Active references % act. ref.
to same field
Bias in peer review 2013 33 102 69%
Effect on peer review of telling reviewers that their signed reviews might be posted on the web: randomised controlled trial 2010 24 9 100%
The Validity of Peer Review in a General Medicine Journal 2011 27 11 82%
THE RELIABILITY OF PEER-REVIEW FOR MANUSCRIPT AND GRANT SUBMISSIONS - A CROSS-DISCIPLINARY INVESTIGATION 1991 181 30 70%
Gender Effects in the Peer Reviews of Grant Proposals: A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Comparing Traditional and Multilevel Approaches 2009 35 40 58%
Impact of peer review on reports of randomised trials published in open peer review journals: retrospective before and after study 2014 11 14 64%
Peer-review in a world with rational scientists: Toward selection of the average 2011 19 5 80%
Effect of blinded peer review on abstract acceptance 2006 49 10 90%
Does mentoring new peer reviewers improve review quality? A randomized trial 2012 10 15 87%
Open peer review by a selected-papers network 2012 8 3 100%

Address terms


Rank Address term Relevance score
(tfidf)		 Class's shr.
of term's tot.
occurrences		 Shr. of publ.
in class containing
term		 Num. of
publ. in
class
1 EVALUAT OFF 10 34% 1.9% 25
2 ST MICHAELS HOSP NEUROL 2 67% 0.2% 2
3 UNITE RECH SCI HUMAINES SOCIALES 2 67% 0.2% 2
4 ADV TECHNOL SURG BRANCH 1 31% 0.3% 4
5 MKT TRADE DEALS 1 100% 0.2% 2
6 SCI PEER ADVISORY REVIEW SERV 1 100% 0.2% 2
7 STROKE EDITORIAL OFF 1 100% 0.2% 2
8 UNITE RECH CLIN ECON SANTE 1 100% 0.2% 2
9 LEHRSTUHL SOZIOL 2 1 27% 0.3% 4
10 HEART DEV STRUCT DIS BRANCH 1 33% 0.2% 2

Related classes at same level (level 1)


Rank Relatedness score Related classes
1 0.0000162285 BIOMED IMAGING INTERVENT JOURNAL//SCIENTIFIC PAPER//MEDICAL WRITING
2 0.0000106124 RESEARCH MISCONDUCT//RESPONSIBLE CONDUCT OF RESEARCH//RESEARCH INTEGRITY
3 0.0000092281 CITATION ERRORS//REFERENCE ACCURACY//QUOTATION ERRORS
4 0.0000079402 H INDEX//JOURNAL OF INFORMETRICS//SCIENTOMETRICS
5 0.0000077821 PUBLICATION RATE//MEETING ABSTRACTS//PUBLICATION BIAS
6 0.0000074417 LEARNED PUBLISHING//INSTITUTIONAL REPOSITORIES//OPEN ACCESS
7 0.0000065812 CURRENT CONTENTS//DELAYED RECOGNITION//COMP SCI LIB
8 0.0000063218 GRANT WRITING//ACC SURVEY REPORT//BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES
9 0.0000059479 JOURNAL OF SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING//UNIVERSITY PRESSES//COMMUNICATIONS SECTOR
10 0.0000059430 IMPROPER PRACTICE//COMMUNICATION OF CLINICAL RESULTS//DISCOVERY GRANTS PROGRAM